Go to the U of M home page
School of Physics & Astronomy
Probe Mission Study Wiki

User Tools

Trace:
oct._18_2017

Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revisionPrevious revision
Next revision		Previous revision
oct._18_2017 [2017/10/17 15:51] – nbattaoct._18_2017 [2017/10/18 10:23] (current) – nbatta
Line 1: Line 1:
 __Oct. 18 2017__ __Oct. 18 2017__
  
-Attendees:+Attendees: Shaul, Jim, Gianfranco, Jean-Baptiste, Mathieu, Alex, Colin, Nick
  
 Agenda: Agenda:
Line 12: Line 12:
 [[Probe_sim_readme|README FILE]] [[Probe_sim_readme|README FILE]]
  
-  Extragalactic Point source and CIB update(Gianfranco)+  Extragalactic Point source and CIB update (Gianfranco)
  
   Cluster lensing update (Jean-Baptiste & Jim)   Cluster lensing update (Jean-Baptiste & Jim)
 +
 +{{::m500lim_vs_z_cmbprobe_polar_all_v2.pdf|CMB Halo lensing update}}
  
   Component separation (Colin, Max, & Nick)   Component separation (Colin, Max, & Nick)
  
-  Lensing (Alex)+  CMB Lensing (Alex) 
 + 
 +{{::cmbprobe_lensingnoise.pdf|CMB Lensing S/N update}}
  
   Cluster update (Nick)   Cluster update (Nick)
  
 +
 +Imager 27200 of clusters and Imager+Spectrometer 19800 of clusters
 +
 +Cluster Cosmology + optical WL mass calibration
 +
 +Imager: sigma Mnu 23.2 meV, w error 5.09 %, sigma wa 0.27
 +
 +Imager + Spectrometer: sigma Mnu 29.9 meV, w error 6.05 %, sigma wa 0.32
  
   Imager discussion   Imager discussion
      
-[[https://docs.google.com/document/d/1HgoAafL4NwJDCTE0fCKQudgXWZtHx6EQU9K-oWm9xvs/edit|Summary table]]+[[https://docs.google.com/document/d/1HgoAafL4NwJDCTE0fCKQudgXWZtHx6EQU9K-oWm9xvs/edit|Summary table of scinece trade-offs]]
  
 {{::colin_hill_spectrometer_science.pdf|Spectrometer Science Slides (Colin H.)}} {{::colin_hill_spectrometer_science.pdf|Spectrometer Science Slides (Colin H.)}}
Line 32: Line 44:
  
 __Minutes__ __Minutes__
 +
 +
 +Simulations are available now.
 +
 +Planck Sky model, following the core cluster paper, 21 frequency bands following the CMB Probe spec (indicated in the Readme). Sky maps Nside=4096 goes to ell of 6000, unit muK (RJ). Components include CMB, Lensing, thermal SZ, kinetic SZ, relativist SZ, CIB, galactic dust, galactic sync, galactic free, AME, points sources for CIB and radio.
 +
 +Each sub directory contains a map at a give frequency.
 +
 +Correlations between extragalactic sources?
 +
 +Differences between PSM and PySM? PySM doesn’t have extra galactic sources.
 +
 +Action item: Jean-Baptiste cluster extractions and check on the 2 highest frequencies
 +
 +CMB Halo lensing
 +
 +Degradation of a factor 2-3 in mass error when we add a spectrometer.
 +
 +11’ arcmin beam you pick up the cluster and 2-halo term (neighbors in the cosmic web). Could fit for this term, but it adds more modeling uncertainty.
 +
 +Action item: Nick will run cosmological parameters with CMB halo lensing mass calibrations
 +
 +Extragalactic point sources
 +
 +50 cm does not add anything new to Planck results beyond the have high frequencies (> 350 GHz) in polarizations. Gianfranco and Mattia will be running new calculations to have quantitative comparisons.
 +
 +CMB Lensing
 +
 +50% reduction in the S/N going to 50 cm imager, the loss isn’t as bad because the EB polarization estimator doesn’t need quite as higher resolution.
 +
 +Brief description of the cluster results and summary table of trade offs
 +
 +Please add or add to any science cases on the table.
oct._18_2017.1508273473.txt.gz · Last modified: 2017/10/17 15:51 by nbatta

Page Tools