===== Sample questions that go beyond the Von Hippel Survey ===== ==== 1. (Prisca) Questions which try to access community response to possible "solutions"==== == Answer these questions with a scale: strongly agree <--> neutral <--> strongly disagree) == * How would the following actions by the funding agencies affect you? * Limiting applicants to one PI or CoI proposal per year: * would increase the time I could spend on my research * would reduce my chances for tenure. * would cause me to leave the field. * would reduce the number of proposals I submit. * would improve the quality of those proposals I submit * would reduce the size of my research group * Calling for proposals every other year * Etc.. * Introducing a pre-proposal stage * Etc... * Introducing an exploratory stage with minimal funding. * Etc... * Reducing the amount of funding for individual proposals * Etc.. * Eliminating one- ==== 2. Personal Choices, tracking futures ==== * If my proposal is rejected, (choose one answer that best represents your action) * I resubmit the same proposal the next year * I submit a different type of proposal the next year * I support my research on someone else's grant * I submit a similar proposal to a different federal funding source * I submit a similar proposal to a private funding source * I concentrate on other aspects of my job (e.g. teaching) * If I am unsuccessful at obtaining federal funding for 5 years, I am most likely to * Switch research fields * Switch jobs into something that does not require resea * Concentrate on non-federal funding sources * Move to another country in order to pursue the same research field ==== 3. Demographics ==== - Which professional organization do you consider your primarily scientific affiliation: AAS, SPD, DPS, other - At what type of institution do you work? Res.U., 2 or 4-yr College, FFRDC, Commercial, other - How many years has it been since you received your terminal degree? - What fraction of your own salary comes from - your home institution? - federally funded competed research grants/contracts (CRG/Cs)? - other projects funded by U.S. govt. agencies (e.g. a NASA mission)? - other sources? - CRG/Cs on which you are the PI? - CRG/Cs on which you are not the PI? - How many CRG/Cs support your own work (at >5% per year)? - Have you submitted a PI proposal in the last 5 years? - If so: - For how many competed research grants/contracts (CRG/Cs)are you the PI? - How many science FTE's are supported by CRG/Cs on which you are the PI? - How many CRG/Cs does it take to support one FTE of science effort? - What has been your personal experience over the last 5 years in terms of proposal success rate? - Over the last 5/10 years, how many initially unsuccessful proposals have you resubmitted in subsequent competitions? - Has your research group gained or lost people over the last 5 years? - In the last 5 years have you, because of funding, changed your professional activities (left the field, retired, worked reduced hours, etc.) - Have you or anyone in your research group left the field? - Were you/they early, mid, or late career? - Where did you/they go? - Have you or anyone in your research group joined the field? - Were you/they early, mid, or late career? - Where did you/they come from? - How many scientists do you consider to be part of your research group? - Does the current CRG/C success rate affect your ability to attract students? Postdocs? Others? - What do you think is the cause of reduced CRG/C success rates? - What is the biggest impact of CRG/C success rate declines over the last several years? - What do you think should be done to address the CRC/C success-rate issue? ==== PLEASE ADD YOUR SECTIONS HERE ====