Go to the U of M home page
School of Physics & Astronomy
Assay and Acquisition of Radiopure Materials

User Tools


aaac:questions:1s

Solution 1: one proposal per year per PI

  • Is it good for the science?
    • Reduce the diversity of ideas? Stifle risky, but imaginative proposals?
      • How many proposals are same PI
      • Rate of success of new PI
      • Do new PIs come up thru the ranks? How many proposals was a PI on as a senior researcher in the past.
      • Size of collaborations, relative number of small vs large collaborations
      • How do we track “new ideas” ?
  • Would it improve success rates?
    • funding requested per proposal, $$ requested for successful vs unsuccessful
    • number of times proposed before success. (and no success attempts)
    • demographics on success vs unsuccessful
  • Would it reduce reviewer load?
    • number of proposals per group, per PI, per faculty vs research vs lab
    • Would it create more PIs (proposals) from otherwise collaborating senior researchers?
    • Does it make it even more difficult to decide between a few very excellent must-fund proposals?
aaac/questions/1s.txt · Last modified: 2014/09/11 15:30 by prisca